SANDUSKY, OHIO — A new report by Einhouse Consulting, LLC provides an independent analysis of the Sandusky State Theatre renovation project. The report was commissioned by the Greater Sandusky Partnership to support the Theatre’s efforts and help the public better understand the challenges and next steps required to complete the project.
According to the report, a contractor was originally brought in by the Theatre’s insurance provider following the 2020 storm damages to stabilize the structure. Early work proceeded smoothly, and the contractor was later selected to lead the reconstruction phase. However, during the rebuilding process, significant disputes emerged. These disputes, along with ongoing insurance complexities, contributed to project delays and uncertainty.
There is an ongoing surety investigation which is expected to conclude at the end of July. The estimated remaining cost to complete the project will be determined at that time.
“This report is intended to provide clarity and cut through the speculation that has surrounded this project,” said Duff Milkie, Board Chair of the Greater Sandusky Partnership. “Our hope is that with this independent analysis, the community has the information it needs to come together and support the successful completion of a project that has such lasting cultural and economic value.”
Tom Einhouse, owner of Einhouse Consulting, LLC, is a nationally recognized expert in historic theatre redevelopment with more than four decades of experience, including leadership roles at Playhouse Square in Cleveland.
“I am grateful for the opportunity to contribute to this important effort. It was a privilege to work alongside the dedicated board and staff of the Sandusky State Theatre, as well as the Greater Sandusky Partnership. I respect the trust they placed in this process, and I look forward to seeing the Theatre move confidently toward its next chapter and to celebrating its grand reopening in the near future,” Tom Einhouse, Einhouse Consulting, LLC.
“We are deeply grateful to the Greater Sandusky Partnership for this generous engagement of Einhouse Consulting. This independent report is a factual narrative of the project which can be shared with our community and stakeholders. The Sandusky State Theatre Board is committed to the completion of this project, so that our historic theatre can return to its mission of providing arts and cultural events to all our residents.
We are indebted to our vast number of forward- thinking supporters, including individuals, the business community through GSP, various public (including the City of Sandusky) and private sector partners, and many generous philanthropic foundations, especially the Randolph J. And Estelle M. Dorn Foundation, and the Erie County Community Foundation,” the Sandusky State Theatre Board mentioned in a joint statement from Colleen Shay Murray, Board Chair, and Tim Parkison, Board Spokesperson.
To access the full report, visit: https://greatersandusky.com/einhouse_sstreport_2025/
